How Much Does a Dental Cavity Filling Cost in 2026?

Dental restorations (fillings) represent the most frequent therapeutic dental procedure in the world. The national average cost to fill a decayed tooth ranges from $150 to $450 per tooth, depending on three primary variables: the material selected (composite resin vs silver amalgam), the number of damaged tooth surfaces involved (1 to 4 surfaces), and whether the tooth is an anterior incisor or posterior molar.

Cost Breakdown by Number of Tooth Surfaces

Number of Tooth Surfaces Tooth-Colored Composite (Resin) Silver Amalgam Typical Insurance Coverage
1 Surface (Occlusal/Chewing) $150 - $260 (D2391) $110 - $190 (D2140) 70% to 80% (Basic Services)
2 Surfaces (MOD Interproximal) $210 - $340 (D2392) $160 - $240 (D2150) 70% to 80% (Basic Services)
3 Surfaces (Multi-cusp) $280 - $420 (D2393) $200 - $310 (D2160) 70% to 80% (Basic Services)
4+ Surfaces (Extensive) $340 - $510 (D2394) $250 - $380 (D2161) Consider Onlay or Crown

The "Alternate Benefit" Insurance Clause

Many legacy dental PPO plans enforce an Amalgam Downgrade Clause for back molar fillings. Even if your dentist places a modern aesthetic composite resin filling, your insurance carrier will calculate reimbursement based on the cheaper silver amalgam fee schedule, leaving you responsible for the difference in cost ($40 to $120 out-of-pocket).